Robin Smith

Review by

Did you ever wonder how photographers get those fabulous pictures of birds? If you have ever tried to take a picture of any moving thing in nature, you’ve probably been perplexed by the work of the pros. I have trouble getting a good photo of a hanging leaf and can’t imagine how anyone could record photos like the ones by talented artists in magazines. Turns out, modern nature photographers have a thing or two to learn from Richard and Cherry Kearton, who invented the concept of bird photography.

Biographies for young children tend to be of familiar folks. But, like the Kearton brothers themselves, Rebecca Bond has taken a risk by writing a picture book biography about obscure brothers with a dream. Bond did her research and has created In the Belly of an Ox: The Unexpected Photographic Adventures of Richard and Cherry Kearton, a lovely, compelling story with wide appeal. The cover shows younger brother Cherry carrying a full size bull on his head! Any typically curious child will want to know what in the world is going on.

Richard and Cherry grew up in a large family in Yorkshire and loved their sheep, the hills and all things rural. Bond’s poetic prose about these young nature lovers draws the reader in: “They especially marveled at the architecture of living things: The structure of nests. The lattice of webs. The shapes of prints. The patterns of play. The camouflage of nature. The designs of flight.” Watercolor richly captures the tone and beauty of the outdoor life the brothers loved. One can imagine Bond, camped out like plein-air artists of the mid-1800s, capturing the green and blue tones of the Yorkshire countryside.

Even though the brothers moved to London as adults, they were drawn back to the moors they loved as boys. And it is here that the story becomes really amazing. The boys, inspired by Cherry’s new camera, decide to photograph a thrush’s nest. They have to be sneaky and clever to capture a good shot of the bird, so they design “hides,” contraptions for camouflage. First, they sew blankets together. Then, they hide in moving bales of hay, inside a hollow tree trunk covered with leaves and even inside a taxidermied ox! Imagine the laughter when young readers see the picture of Cherry, upside down in the ox, when a strong wind blows him over! Such ingenuity and dedication lead the brothers to become famous naturalists and writers, and to lead the lives they loved.

A full spread of period photographs and fascinating author notes rounds out this marvel of a story. Modern photographers with their teeny digital cameras will be inspired to follow the Keartons’ lead and find new ways to capture nature in photography

Robin Smith occasionally catches a slow spider in her camera’s lens, but never a bird.

Did you ever wonder how photographers get those fabulous pictures of birds? If you have ever tried to take a picture of any moving thing in nature, you’ve probably been perplexed by the work of the pros. I have trouble getting a good photo of a hanging leaf and can’t imagine how anyone could record […]
Review by

Poet, mother, hiker, Coloradan—these are all words that describe Carrie Host. But in October 2003, another word was added to the list: patient. Shortly after the birth of her third child, in the midst of unexplained, excruciating pain, Host’s life changed dramatically. What was initially thought to be an ovarian cyst, then a ruptured appendix, turned out to be rare and difficult-to-treat carcinoid tumors that had spread to her abdomen, liver and lungs.

Host’s Between Me and the River goes where many cancer stories go—the search for the right doctors, painful and humiliating tests, terrifying Internet searches, bouts of depression, surgeries and treatments. But this is no mere “cancer book.” The author, while sparing none of the difficult and horrifying details, tells her story with dignity and humor and gives credit where it is due: her husband and teenage children are her anchor and her siblings, doctors, and friends steer the boat when the river, which is the metaphor that holds this memoir together, threatens to drown her.

It’s easy to see who might enjoy this story (and, despite the heavy topic, it is a joy to read)—folks with illness and their friends and family. There is one group that should read it: doctors. Host mostly has good doctors, who listen to her story and carefully consider how they will answer her questions. They are not flip or dismissive and understand that a patient hangs on every word, listening for doubt or worry. When one of her doctors makes a mistake, he apologizes and accepts the fact that he is not God. Doctors don’t often hear how their words and actions can make such a difference to the patient and the family. Host’s clear memory of the most critical times in her illness will change the lives of doctors who take the time to read it.

It is sometimes difficult to read a story like this that hits close to home for any of us who have fought cancer or lived with someone who has, but Host’s sure voice and careful explanations allow us onto the boat with her, sure that, in the end, whatever that end might be, we will be better for the trip.

Robin Smith is a reader, teacher and cancer survivor in Nashville. 

Poet, mother, hiker, Coloradan—these are all words that describe Carrie Host. But in October 2003, another word was added to the list: patient. Shortly after the birth of her third child, in the midst of unexplained, excruciating pain, Host’s life changed dramatically. What was initially thought to be an ovarian cyst, then a ruptured appendix, […]
Review by

According to my records, I have read The Wizard of Oz 17 times. That’s a conservative estimate and doesn’t count the number of times I heard the book read aloud when I was a child. I have defended L. Frank Baum’s work from detractors who find it didactic or flat, and I have watched the eyes of more than 300 second-graders as they absorb the story of Dorothy and her adventures.

Grace Lin’s latest book, Where the Mountain Meets the Moon, is part Chinese legend, part Zen storytelling, part feminist-inspired folktale and many parts Oz. My list of “things that are just like Oz” includes: a girl on a journey for a magical being, a friend who needs help, a brick road, cliffhanger chapter endings, old-fashioned full-color illustrations and a dramatic tone. But, despite my long list, Lin’s adventure story reads like an homage to Oz rather than a story derived from it.

Our heroine, Minli, spends her family’s hard-earned money on a goldfish that is supposed to change their fortune. Ma is the keeper of the money, and she complains constantly about her family’s impoverished state. The stories of the talking goldfish inspire Minli to set out on a journey to Never-Ending Mountain, where she will ask the Old Man in the Moon for help.

Following the traditions of the hero myth, Lin portrays Minli as she travels far from home, carrying items that end up being important for her survival. She meets a magical and beloved dragon companion who helps her see what is really important. She meets and overcomes challenges and has to complete her mission alone. And, in the end, Minli learns what she is supposed to learn. Every character in the story changes and grows during the time that Minli is away.

My future second-graders are going to love Minli and her stories when I read this book to them next year. They will see the similarities to Oz, but that will only make the story better for them. Suspenseful without being scary, complex without being complicated, this spirited tale of self-discovery and fate has a little something for every reader.

 

Robin Smith shares Oz and other stories with her second-grade class in Nashville.

According to my records, I have read The Wizard of Oz 17 times. That’s a conservative estimate and doesn’t count the number of times I heard the book read aloud when I was a child. I have defended L. Frank Baum’s work from detractors who find it didactic or flat, and I have watched the […]
Review by

You know when people refer to “a book for all ages?” That usually means they are speaking in clichés. But in the new picture book Duck! Rabbit!, the cliché proves true. I know—I met two fans of the book on a flight to Baltimore last weekend. I was wedged into the middle seat but wanted to get some work done, so I pulled out a copy of Duck! Rabbit! and began reading. I soon realized with joy that the engineering student to my left and the beefy salesman to my right were watching the pages turn and chuckling with delight. They actually wanted me to read it again!

To get an idea of the book’s concept, think back to those pictures from your Psych 101 textbook, the ones that looked like an old hag or a young woman, depending on your perception. Author Amy Krouse Rosenthal and illustrator Tom Lichtenheld have fashioned an utterly captivating riff on those pictures. Readers will see a duck or a rabbit, depending on where their head is.

Thick black ink outlines the duck/rabbit and serves as a visual anchor for the story. The figure morphs as the animals are shown eating, drinking, running and flying, all while the duck/rabbit image holds steady inside those thick black outlines. When I read the book aloud, children giggled and gasped when they realized there was no right answer to the question of the character’s identity. This uncertainty makes the book wonderfully re-readable. The text is easy and accessible for the earliest reader, but the ideas are intellectually satisfying for the adults who want to join the fun. At the end of the story, the illustrator thanks Eric Rohmann, whose My Friend Rabbit is suggested here at many turns. That earlier book would make a lovely companion to this one.

Hop (or swim) and find a Duck! Rabbit! of your very own!

Robin Smith reads books aloud to her second-graders in Nashville, and sometimes to perfect strangers on planes.
 

You know when people refer to “a book for all ages?” That usually means they are speaking in clichés. But in the new picture book Duck! Rabbit!, the cliché proves true. I know—I met two fans of the book on a flight to Baltimore last weekend. I was wedged into the middle seat but wanted […]
Review by

What is it about the lives of dolls? Kids love thinking about what their dolls do when they are alone, away from the prying eyes of their owners. And who hasn't had a little chat with a doll or stuffed animal at some point? I know I have.

Ann M. Martin, Laura Godwin and Brian Selznick (hot on the heels of his Caldecott win for The Invention of Hugo Cabret) collaborate on the third episode of their Doll People series in The Runaway Dolls. Opening with 12 pages of detailed pencil drawings, Selznick draws the reader right in. The same sense of fun and derring – do permeate the plot as Annabelle Doll, the tiny dollhouse heroine of the two previous books, finds a mysterious package, puts all of doll – kind in jeopardy with her rash decisions and runs away from her beloved family. This series is the perfect bridge between short chapter books and longer books like Harry Potter, which, though thrilling, can bog down young readers. Though the subject matter might seem a tad girly, the intrigue and suspense will grab boys and girls. The new doll in this installment is baby Tilly May, who has been lost behind a cabinet, in her original packaging, for more than 100 years. As it turns out, Tilly May is the long – lost baby of the Doll family. She has spotty knowledge of the modern world because she has listened to a "fing called the radio" for years and years. Her charming mispronunciation of the "th" sound is just one her adorable traits. Tilly May's wide-eyed curiosity just about drives her sister crazy, but it will bring chortles of amusement and recognition to any reader who has a younger sibling.

Martin and Godwin craft a complicated story with many characters that is still a breeze to follow. Though we all know that everything will turn out fine in the end, the story has enough twists to keep the pages turning. This is an old-fashioned tale with new-fashioned fun—I wish I had some children left at home so I could read it aloud. Maybe I'll find a doll or a teddy bear who'll listen.

What is it about the lives of dolls? Kids love thinking about what their dolls do when they are alone, away from the prying eyes of their owners. And who hasn't had a little chat with a doll or stuffed animal at some point? I know I have. Ann M. Martin, Laura Godwin and Brian […]
Review by

Bob Shea is back with the same energy and humor that marked his earlier offerings, Big Plans and New Socks. This time, he nails the bravado of the young child right on the head.

Nothing can stop Dinosaur, not a pile of leaves, a big slide, a bowl of spaghetti, talking grown – ups or even bath time and tooth brushing. But, when Dinosaur faces bedtime, his energy and confidence are put to the test. The opening "ROAR! I'M A DINOSAUR!" will pull young listeners into the world of this appealing dinosaur instantly. Short red legs propel it to each new challenge and its spiky, white, oversized teeth seem ready for anything. The new reader will cheer along with the joyful "DINOSAUR WINS!" that follows each new success and will grin with recognition at each roar and chomp. Who hasn't seen a youngster brazenly cheer for himself when overcoming an obstacle? A mixture of collage and cartoon – like illustrations gives the book a bit of a retro feel, which will appeal to the adult reader, especially when the dinosaur dons its blue and white striped pajamas.

Repeating phrases, familiar words and universal situations will make this a book that any child will gravitate to and giggle over. It won't be long until the child is reading right along, maybe even by herself. Children who are just about to learn to read need easy text, engaging illustrations and lots of repetition and this hilarious offering gives healthy doses of each.

Prepare your dinosaur voices and exaggerated roars, because this is a read – aloud that children will ask for over and over. When it comes to Dinosaur vs. the mom or dad reader, Dinosaur wins!

 

Robin Smith is a second grade teacher in Nashville.

Bob Shea is back with the same energy and humor that marked his earlier offerings, Big Plans and New Socks. This time, he nails the bravado of the young child right on the head. Nothing can stop Dinosaur, not a pile of leaves, a big slide, a bowl of spaghetti, talking grown – ups or […]
Review by

In her latest book, Ann Hood, author of last year's semi-autobiographical novel The Knitting Circle, puts the reader on the harrowing frontlines of every parent's worst nightmare: a crisis involving a child. Comfort: A Journey Through Grief is Hood's account of the death of her daughter, Grace, and the aftermath of her loss. This is an intensely personal, painfully moving collection of essays that take readers to a place no one wants to visit.

Grace was a healthy, vibrant five-year-old when she contracted an especially virulent form of strep that ravaged her internal organs and, in less than 48 hours, took her life. Suddenly Grace was gone, leaving a heartbroken mother, father and eight-year-old brother, Sam. Hood could find no solace. The platitudes issued by well-meaning friends and relatives (recounted in the book's searing first chapter) only made things worse. It was when she learned to knit and joined a knitting group at a local yarn store that she was able to move toward some sort of healing. And, when Hood and her family adopt a new baby, joy finally returns to her life.

Hood's honest recounting of the terrible day and all the terrible days that followed does not spare the reader, instead giving an idea of just what havoc the death of a child causes. Reading what helped her (the dinners, the cards, the listeners, the knitting) might help the rest of us who wonder what to do and what to say when our friends and relatives face loss. Reading Comfort is a wrenching experience, but, when I shared this book with a dear friend who had lost a child, he agreed that Hood talks about loss in the most honest, useful way he has ever read. He was comforted by her words, even as they brought him back to the day when his own daughter died.

There are so many empty phrases that people say to those who have suffered loss, but the real truth is clear to Hood: "Time does not heal. It just passes."

 

Robin Smith reads, teaches and knits in Nashville.

In her latest book, Ann Hood, author of last year's semi-autobiographical novel The Knitting Circle, puts the reader on the harrowing frontlines of every parent's worst nightmare: a crisis involving a child. Comfort: A Journey Through Grief is Hood's account of the death of her daughter, Grace, and the aftermath of her loss. This is […]
Review by

I wonder if Thomas Dorflein, the zookeeper at the Berlin Zoo, ever thought he would spend half a year as a foster parent to a polar bear? When Tosca, a female polar bear at the zoo, gave birth to two healthy cubs, she showed little interest in her offspring. The veterinarians and zookeepers had to step in quickly to save them. After one of the cubs died of a fever, Dorflein became the around-the-clock caregiver for Knut. Any parent can empathize with Dorflein's long nights and the constant feeding, grooming and cleaning that Knut required. The zookeeper's own family had to move to the back burner as the baby polar bear's needs demanded almost every minute of his foster father's time and energy. And when one animal rights activist declared that zookeepers should never have intervened to save the cub, little Knut became a worldwide celebrity.

In Knut: How One Little Polar Bear Captivated the World, it's the details that make the story memorable the nine-part photograph of Knut eating his first meal of kitten food and milk, his struggles with teething pain and his rollicking fun in the sandbox will remind young readers of the similarities between humans and their furry mammal relatives. Juliana, Isabella and Craig Hatkoff, authors of the popular Owen & Mzee, join forces here with Gerald Ulrich, CEO of the Berlin Zoo, to turn this story of one adorable and irresistible polar bear into much more. They highlight the effect of human civilization and global warming on the habitat of all polar bears and pose a painful question: Is it possible that polar bears could become extinct during our lifetime?

Detailed back matter will send interested readers deeper into the lives of polar bears and to scientific information about ecological activism. One very cute, very vulnerable polar bear cub might just do what the politicians seem unable to do: mobilize humans to pay attention to the effect they have on the Earth.

I wonder if Thomas Dorflein, the zookeeper at the Berlin Zoo, ever thought he would spend half a year as a foster parent to a polar bear? When Tosca, a female polar bear at the zoo, gave birth to two healthy cubs, she showed little interest in her offspring. The veterinarians and zookeepers had to […]
Review by

It's 1875 and the wounds from the Civil War are still raw for the poor and struggling folks of Mississippi. The houses have been razed, the trees burned for fuel, and the men are injured, maimed and mired in sadness. Times are tough and life is full of danger from ruffians and vigilantes. The slaves have been freed, but they are just as tied to white landowners as they ever were. Across the swamp is a wooded no-man's-land called No-Bob, populated by the O'Donnells, a family known for their cruelty, bloodthirstiness and constant unpleasant presence, usually begging for money and food. They marry young, bear children and marry them off to each other.

Addy's father is the meanest and fiercest of all the O'Donnells, and when he leaves his wife and heads for Texas, his bereft wife abandons her daughter to follow him. This leaves Addy in the care of newlyweds Frank and Irene, the schoolmaster and his wife. Addy's extremely rough upbringing has prepared her well she knows how to build a fire, keep a house, build a shed and keep herself alive on next to no food. When her father resurfaces, stealing eggs from Frank's chicken coop, Addy must return to No-Bob with him. Pappy. He is bad and mean and dangerous, but he is still my Pappy, she says. When Addy discovers a devastating secret about her father and his connection to the violence that is running rampant in the area, she makes the hardest decision of her life.

In this sequel to her Civil War novel, How I Found the Strong, Margaret McMullan has created a deeply philosophical, first-person account of life in the Reconstruction era that is heartbreaking and uplifting at the same time. Echoes of the present are impossible to miss life under occupation, the reaction of the insurgent Klan, and aching poverty. It's the kind of book I love, one that makes me want to read everything McMullan has written. Twice.

It's 1875 and the wounds from the Civil War are still raw for the poor and struggling folks of Mississippi. The houses have been razed, the trees burned for fuel, and the men are injured, maimed and mired in sadness. Times are tough and life is full of danger from ruffians and vigilantes. The slaves […]
Review by

On its face, Gennifer Choldenko's first novel is the story of Kirsten, a seventh-grader whose life seems to be falling apart. She has put on a lot of weight, her parents are arguing, and, when school begins, her best friends have joined the mean girls group, leaving her alone. But there is much more to this story.

Choldenko's accessible, amusing novel in two voices turns its penetrating eye on the social vibe at a San Francisco private school and its students and families. Everyone in this moneyed society is trying to find out where he or she belongs. Kirsten narrates her chapters with a fresh, nervous, insecure voice that could be Every Nice Seventh-Grade Girl. She worries about her clothes, her backpack, her seat at lunch, the way her hair looks and her weight. She hates her giggle, her voice, the way her fat wiggles when she runs. The other narrator is a third person voice that sounds a lot like the other main character. Walk is confident, secure and not at all concerned about how others perceive him. He is new to Mountain School, a black kid from the decaying City School, on scholarship. Brianna, the blonde Alpha-girl, will be recognizable to anyone who can still remember middle school. With a sneaky smile, a rich mom willing to make things happen for her little girl and a cadre of buddies longing to do her bidding, Brianna seems to have everyone wrapped around her finger, and Walk just doesn't get it. What is her power? Why does she matter?

There are so many fascinating characters in this story: mothers who are overly concerned with their social standing; students who spend more time worrying about their social life than academics; one lovely boy who is willing to sell Amway to save money for private school; adults who must come to terms with the secrets they have kept for far too long; and kids who try to figure out if they matter. This is a perfect book for classroom or parent-child book clubs. It begs to be read over and over.

 

Robin Smith is a second-grade teacher in Nashville.

On its face, Gennifer Choldenko's first novel is the story of Kirsten, a seventh-grader whose life seems to be falling apart. She has put on a lot of weight, her parents are arguing, and, when school begins, her best friends have joined the mean girls group, leaving her alone. But there is much more to […]
Review by

How would you feel if your mortal enemy showed up at a tea with you? That is just the dilemma faced by the three pigs, Little Red Riding Hood and a host of children's book characters in Judy Sierra's hilarious new offering for young readers.

Now living in the Villain Villa Senior Center, and faced with the challenges of living on a fixed income, B.B. Wolf is thrilled to see something besides bills (from damage to the Pigs' house and cleaning bills from Granny, for example) in his mailbox, especially after huffing and puffing his way there. What's this he sees? An invitation to tea from his local librarian? When his friend the crocodile warns him he will have to behave himself, B.B. Wolf is worried. But, thanks to the help of his friend, a handy etiquette book and a superb manners jingle, B.B. Wolf is ready for the big day . . . and the cookies.

Otto Siebold is a master at computer illustration. It's amazing that a modern tool can create such retro art. B.B. Wolf, clad in an orange and yellow plaid suit with striped pants, bifocals perched on his substantial nose, looks like any other grandfather, even while singing the tune that he invents to remember his manners. Experienced readers will recognized all the icons of children's books when B.B., complete with a scary wolfish shadow, strides into the library. Besides Goldilocks, Bo-Peep and the three pigs, careful eyes will spy Humpty Dumpty, the Gingerbread Man, the Little Engine (that could), Elmer the Elephant and a little mouse I can't quite name, but certainly have seen before. Siebold uses the familiar echoes of critters from the mass market books of the '60s, but jazzes them up with his signature style.

Listeners and readers will surely sing along with B.B.'s song, and maybe even learn a little bit about manners along the way. But mostly they will be smiling and guffawing every time they think about the explosive belch that spreads across a double-page spread. Excuuuse you, Mr. Wolf!

How would you feel if your mortal enemy showed up at a tea with you? That is just the dilemma faced by the three pigs, Little Red Riding Hood and a host of children's book characters in Judy Sierra's hilarious new offering for young readers. Now living in the Villain Villa Senior Center, and faced […]
Review by

To read poet and novelist Naomi Shihab Nye's tales of driving and being driven is to hear her voice in every syllable. Like her poetry, mostly written for adults, Nye's prose comes from deep within a heart that believes, more that anything else, in the power of human connection.

Thirty-one stories of conversations and adventures while in cars make up I'll Ask You Three Times, Are You OK? Nye's gift is her ability to ask the right questions, remember the answers and recount them in a way that erases the distance between writer and reader. I nod in agreement when she remarks that all we see of taxi drivers are the sides and backs of their heads. And, when she is in a car accident (in a friend's car), I feel her sadness and responsibility as she surveys the damage to the totaled GTO.

In Dora, Naomi finds herself with an unexpected passenger shortly after finally passing her driver's test: An old lady who speaks only Spanish plunks herself in the back of the car and will not get out. This situation had not been included in the dull driving manual I had been poring over, reluctantly, for more than a year. So far every problem I had encountered in my life had not been predicted or described by anyone in advance. Indeed. And since she does not quite know what to do with this lady, now called Dora, she takes her home to her own mother, who helps her find her home.

These stories are for any age children will nod and laugh in recognition while adult readers will find themselves grabbing for a slip of paper to write down quotations and sentences to treasure. Poignant, hilarious, terrifying and always soul-sustaining, Nye's stories remind us what it is to be truly human. Put on your seatbelt; you're in for a satisfying read.

 

Robin Smith drives her late-model Saturn in Nashville when she can't get her husband to do the driving.

To read poet and novelist Naomi Shihab Nye's tales of driving and being driven is to hear her voice in every syllable. Like her poetry, mostly written for adults, Nye's prose comes from deep within a heart that believes, more that anything else, in the power of human connection. Thirty-one stories of conversations and adventures […]
Review by

Let me admit this right now: I like to grow plants and I have stood for hours at garden shops, weighing the difference between worm castings and cow manure. So, I understand the care that 11-year-old Mildred takes when she sets out to win the Circleville, Ohio, Pumpkin Show. I feel her anxiety when she has to thin out the seedlings and leave the growing fruit behind during a weekend trip.

Mildred is trying, once again, to fulfill her late mother's dream of growing a prize-winning pumpkin. Each year, her dreams are dashed for one reason or another. And, while the seasons are changing and the pumpkins are growing, Mildred is growing too. Her Aunt Arlene tries to notice the changes and, in her own loving but pushy way, encourages Mildred to pay attention to fashion and other girlie things. Arlene worries about Mildred's obsession with pumpkins and does her best to encourage her to follow other pursuits. Luckily for Mildred, her father not only understands his only child, he knows how to challenge her to grow into the strong young woman her mother always knew she would become.

In Me and the Pumpkin Queen, author Marlane Kennedy paints a warm picture of a real family, quietly going about the job of living each day, healing and growing pumpkins. Young readers and listeners will enjoy finding out how things turn out for Mildred. This marvelously heartwarming story deserves a big blue ribbon!

Let me admit this right now: I like to grow plants and I have stood for hours at garden shops, weighing the difference between worm castings and cow manure. So, I understand the care that 11-year-old Mildred takes when she sets out to win the Circleville, Ohio, Pumpkin Show. I feel her anxiety when she […]

Sign Up

Stay on top of new releases: Sign up for our newsletter to receive reading recommendations in your favorite genres.

Trending Features