Jerusalem

One City, Three Faiths

By Karen Armstrong
Alfred A. Knopf, $30

ISBN 0679435964

Buy or borrow this book!

Support your local independent bookseller

Find it in a WorldCat library

Compare prices at major online bookstores


Review by Janice Penkalski

One needs only to turn on the nightly news to hear about the latest atrocities in the "holy city" of Jerusalem. Yet all the great religions insist that the true test of spirituality is practical compassion. A city, according to author Karen Armstrong, cannot be holy unless it also treats the weak and vulnerable justly and with compassion. It cannot gain access to its great sanctity apart from the quest for social justice and charity.

The struggle to uncover the meaning of "holy city" prompted Armstrong to write the historically comprehensive and engaging Jerusalem: One City, Three Faiths. In it, she explores the almost 4,000-year-old history of this sacred and controversial city called Ir David by Jews, New Jerusalem by Christians, and al-Quds, "the Holy," by Muslims.

Her exploration was a formidable task. Jerusalem's conquered and conquerors change quickly as the city is ruthlessly destroyed over and over again-along with its inhabitants, its temples, mosques, churches, and holy shrines.

Of all of Jerusalem's victors, including the Muslims, Armstrong faults the Christians for creating the rift that has endured through the present day. "Ever since the Crusades, which permanently damaged relations between the three religions of Abraham, Jerusalem has been a nervous, defensive city," says Armstrong.

Armstrong's previous book, the best-selling The History of God, was heralded for its lucid synthesis of the search for the sacred and the shaping of the concept of God by the three dominant monotheistic religions-Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. She has succeeded again, weaving religious myth with historical research in an accessible style. Moreover, Armstrong provides a foundation that is useful in understanding the motivation, the thinking, the belief system of the religious groups that have identified and continue to identify with Jerusalem as the place where the divine meets with the mundane world.

Jerusalem is valuable not only because of its detailed historical analysis but because the author illuminates, as well, Jerusalem's spiritual significance. Armstrong's book is a plea for that significance to surface in Jerusalem today.


Janice Penkalski teaches and writes in Lexington, Kentucky.


©1996, ProMotion, inc.


www@bookpage.com