The Prince of the Marshes
|
After Afghanistan, a year in Iraq
REVIEW BY HOWARD SHIRLEY Following the ouster of Saddam Hussein, British diplomat Rory Stewart was asked to serve as the deputy governor of two southern Iraqi provinces. Stewart was already familiar with the Muslim way of life, having spent nearly two years walking across the Middle East, from Turkey to Nepal, including a hazardous solo trek across a desolate Afghanistan, recorded in his previous book The Places in Between. By comparison, his yearlong assignment in Iraq seemed simple: help the local people transition from dictatorship to democracy. The Prince of the Marshes is Stewart's account of that year, trying to mold a place of modern order out of a culture caught in medieval chaos. The book is not a record of accomplishments, nor a criticism of excesses. It is simply one man's story of a struggle to have a lasting effect in a land where a single day of violence could turn months of success into ashes. In the midst of this, Stewart was forced to find allies among political parties led by militant clerics, agents of the Iranian secret police and a local warlord (the man for whom the book is named). Unfortunately, any of these "allies" might treat him as a best friend in the morning, and lob mortar rounds on his roof that night. Whether Stewart's actions as governor were always the wisest might be subject to debate. But then, Stewart's book shows clearly how any choice he made became a matter of "damned if you do, damned if you don't." His riveting account of a desperate three-day stand against a militia attack on his office in Nasiriyah is a harrowing reminder of just how fragile and dangerous each decision could be. Stewart shares his experiences without gloss or self-praise. His writing is careful and spartan, and all the better for it. Rather than glorify, politicize or rant, Stewart simply describes what he experienced and the local leaders he encountered—the good, the bad, and the in-between. Regardless of how you feel about the war and the efforts to recast a fractured nation, The Prince of the Marshes offers insight into a turbulent land whose troubles have yet to end.
War stories
Neil MacFarquhar's The Sand Café opens just before the first Iraq war, but this satire of war reporting could have been written about today's press. MacFarquhar is Cairo bureau chief for the New York Times.
By Neil MacFarquhar Public Affairs, $24.95 384 pages ISBN 1586483684
By David Axe ComicsLit, $15.95 96 pages ISBN 1561634638
By Scott Anderson Doubleday, $24.95 374 pages ISBN 0385515561
Howard Shirley is a writer in Franklin, Tennessee.
|
Support your 
The current situation in the Middle East has inspired fiction as well as memoirs like Stewart's. Three journalists who have spent time in the region take on the topic in new novels.
Journalist David Axe has been embedded with troops in Iraq, and his experiences informed the graphic roman à clef War-Fix, illustrated by Steven Olexa. Axe portrays war's violence while also taking an honest look at the thrill that defying death can inspire.
Moonlight Hotel by war reporter Scott Anderson focuses on the politics behind war. An American diplomat in the Middle East finds his life of leisure interrupted when the U.S. steps in to regulate a tribal conflict.